Scientific Consensus Statement for Great Barrier Reef

You are currently viewing Scientific Consensus Statement for Great Barrier Reef

Over the past two years, a large multi-authored report has been put together to give a definite statement for the impacts of water quality on the Great Barrier Reef. The Statement involved more than 200 experts, 78 authors and 69 reviewers from Australia and overseas, with the outputs based on evidence from over 4,000 publications – making it one of the most comprehensive and rigorous review ever undertaken of the influence of land-based activities on Great Barrier Reef water quality and ecosystem condition, and the management actions that can support water quality improvements.

The 2022 Scientific Consensus Statement adopted a consistent, structured and systematic evidence-based approach to address 30 questions led by expert authors and was independently peer reviewed. It was put together to ensure that policy or management decisions are based on consideration of the full synthesis of the evidence.

Two of our NP-GAN partners were authors within the consensus statement. Cefas (Michelle Devlin) contributed to the overview statement, led by Jane Waterhouse from C2O Consulting and representing a strong cross section of scientists working across the catchment to coast issues. Guided by an expert working group and best practice to reach a consensus on eight overarching conclusions, the 2022 Scientific Consensus Statement concluded that:

  • Pollutant loads are well above pre-development rates, where they come from, and how they enter waterways.
  • Knowledge of some of the most effective management actions for improving water quality has been strengthened.
  • Improved understanding of the importance of good water quality in the context of climate change, especially around ecosystem recovery following disturbance events, and the distribution and impacts of pesticide mixtures, hotspots for pesticide management, expanded scope of evidence on other pollutants, and further clarification of the potential benefits of best management practices.
  • The need for greater emphasis on social values, the importance of landholder trust in government, scientists and programme delivery organisations in engendering management practice change and greater collaboration among everyone involved in water quality management.
Catchment to reef infographic

Infographic of catchment to reef connections across environment, people and health.

Under the theme ‘Exploring the human dimensions of water quality improvements and emerging science’, Michelle Devlin and Amelia Wenger from Wildlife Conservation Society were co-authors for one of the chapters with Dr Amelia Wenger, looking at the effectiveness and efficiency of land management approaches for improved water quality.

The chapter looks at the key attributes of successful monitoring and evaluation programmes to support coastal and marine water quality management, and provides examples of innovative monitoring and evaluation frameworks, methods and approaches that are applicable to the Great Barrier Reef. Many of the lessons learnt from Cefas’ national and international work formed part of this narrative.

Working on this chapter was incredibly satisfying but also challenging. The process was long and involved many months of searching and reviewing literature to ensure that every reference was non-biased with high confidence in the science quality, which then had to be agreed by an external board.  We had to build on the outcomes of the last SCS, but to also look to the future at examples of more integrated monitoring programmes that encompass environmental, social and economic values. Many scientists, managers and stakeholders were part of the process, recognising how important it is to ensure our science and the communication of those messages can counter false or incorrect narratives, particularly important for the many issues facing the Great Barrier Reef.
Prof. Michelle Devlin
Prof. Michelle Devlin
Senior research Scientist

Prof. Devlin advised that the Consensus Statement also forms a critical part of the new UN Decade Programme – Nutrient Pollution – Global Action Network – NP-GAN, where the team has partnered with the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority.

We will continue to work closely with them [Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority] on solutions for improved land management and identifying case studies where implementation of best management practices has helped protect our coastal and marine systems.
Prof. Michelle Devlin
Prof. Michelle Devlin
Senior research Scientist

Leave a Reply